SECOND MARRIAGE AFTER CONVERSION TO ISLAM WHILE FIRST MARRIAGE SUBSISTS WOULD AMOUNT TO BIGAMY UNDER HINDU MARRIAGE LAW AND INDIAN PENAL CODE Aapka Consultant Judgment Series- In this series, we are providing case analysis of Landmark Judgments of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. The couple will be allowed to marry only if the official finds no objections. Earlier, the state's top elected leader, Yogi Aditynatah, a Hindu monk, said at a public meeting that those waging “love jihad” should either refrain from it or be prepared to die. (1932) 2 Cal. Yamunanagar: A 21-year-old Muslim man converted to Hinduism before marrying a 19-year-old Hindu woman. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service. Mohan was with Seema Bishnoi, his wife of 13 years, when he met and fell in love with Bali. The new decree comes at a time when Indian politics are increasingly becoming religiously charged. Dharmendra belongs to a Arya Samaj Hindu Punjabi Jatt family. In fact, the second marriage will be invalid. The second marriage would be void in terms of the provisions of Section 494 IPC and the apostate-husband would be guilty of the offence under Section 494 IPC. While she will be entitled to Mehr, she cannot inherit her husband’s property. Therefore, if the man in question becomes a Muslim and then you both marry, the marriage would be valid, even if there was a relationship prior to the marriage which was not permissible. She is settled in the USA. The decree was passed Tuesday and follows a campaign by Modi’s Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party against interfaith marriages. Under the decree — which will become a law after its approval by the state’s governor, a formality — a couple belonging to two different religions will have to give two months’ notice to a district magistrate before getting married. India’s ruling Hindu nationalist party has approved legislation in Uttar Pradesh, the country’s most populous state, that lays out a prison term of up to 10 years for anyone found guilty of using marriage to force someone to change religion. A Hindu marriage solemnised under the Act can only be dissolved on any of the grounds specified under the Act. While the wife in such a case will be entitled to dower (mehr), she cannot inherit her husband’s property, the Supreme Court has ruled. Muslim man converts to Hinduism before marriage, couple under Haryana Police protection Digital Desk December 1, 2020. Amid a rising tide of Hindu nationalism in India under Modi, Hindu hard-line groups have long accused minority Muslims of taking over the country by … QnA: What is the greatest punishment for bigamy? Supreme Court on feigned conversion to Islam and second marriage-II By Mushtaq Ahmad 4. Relationship Pitfalls And How To Avoid Them, Bihar elections: PM Modi praises Nitish Kumar for 'sushasan', takes dig at Lalu Yadav, Interview with Table Tennis Champion Harmeet Desai, Gurpurab 2020 Vrat Kadha: Gurpurab 2020 significance, rituals & special prasad on this day, Jackets for men: Smart hooded sweatshirts for men, Chicken noodles: Mouth-watering options that will please everyone. NEW DELHI -- India’s ruling Hindu nationalist party has approved legislation in the country’s most populous state that lays out a prison term of up to 10 years for anyone found guilty of using marriage to force someone to change religion. The party describes such marriages as “love jihad,” an unproven conspiracy theory used by its leaders and Hindu hard-line groups to accuse Muslim men of converting Hindu women by marriage. Therefore after converting religion to christian or Muslim is it legal to marry second time before divorce of first hindu wife ? Earlier, she had opined that the anti-conversion law introduced by UP govt should be nationalized so as to reduce the “struggle for women like me who are fighting the toxicity of religion in inter-faith marriages”. (John Jiban Chandra Datta v. Abinash, I.L.R. These men then, apparently, smooth talk women into converting to Islam … The party denies the accusation. Since long time, married males whose personal law does not permit bigamous marriage have been making use of the unhealthy and unethical ways of converting to Islam for the sake of contracting a second bigamous marriage under a perception that such conversion allows them to marry once again without getting their first marriage ceased. Thus, an Indian Christian domiciled in India can, after his conversion to Islam, legally contract a second marriage with a Muslim woman while his former marriage with a Christian woman is still subsisting. Yamunanagar: A Muslim man in Haryana converted to Hinduism before marrying a Hindu woman. They said the ad promoted “love jihad.". Critics of Modi — an avowed Hindu nationalist — say India’s tradition of diversity and secularism has come under attack since his party won power in 2014 and returned for a second term in 2019. Existence of an existing valid marriage is an essential condition to prove the said offence. According to the Hindu Marriage Act, a Hindu cannot marry a second time while the first wife is still alive. The party describes such marriages as “love jihad,” an unproven conspiracy theory used by its leaders and Hindu hard-line groups to accuse Muslim men of converting Hindu women by marriage. Now, the couple is under police protection here following the intervention of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, The New Indian Express (TNIE). The Hindu Marriage Act 1955 does not allow a man to take a second wife so Mohan converted to Islam. Conversion to islam is often used as a shield to protect the conviction under section 494. On Monday, police registered a case against two executives of online streaming service Netflix, after a leader of Modi's party objected to scenes in the series “A Suitable Boy,” in which a Hindu girl and a Muslim boy kiss against the backdrop of what appears to be a Hindu temple. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? Relationships: ‘Romantic Burn-Outs’ Exist: And Here Are The Signs! Statutory Provisions The position under the various statutes is discussed below. As to (iii), the converts Marriage Dissolution Act, 1866, which seeks to legalise, under certain circumstances, the dissolution of marriage of converts to Christianity, is the only relevant statute. 12) They accuse the party of fanning religious passions and presiding over religious intolerance and sometimes even violence. The party describes such marriages as “love jihad,” an unproven conspiracy theory used by its leaders and Hindu hard-line groups to accuse Muslim men of converting Hindu women by marriage. The second marriage after conversion to Islam would, thus, be in violation of the rules … ... focus on conversion by marriage… It was contended in Sarla Mudgal’s case that making a convert Hindu liable for prosecution under the Penal Code would be against Islam, the religion adopted by such person upon conversion. “Assuming that a Hindu husband has a right to embrace Islam as his religion, he has no right under the Act to marry again without getting his marriage under the Act dissolved. Wife of Arun Gawli, notorious gangster turned politician from Mumbai, India. Last month, jewelry brand Tanishq withdrew an advertisement featuring a Hindu-Muslim family celebrating a baby shower from TV channels and its social media platforms, following a backlash from Hindu nationalists and Modi's party leaders. But an apparent mood of fear, anger and disenchantment is growing among ordinary Indian Muslims. Hindu Law Under s. 13(1)(ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: Muslim man converts to Hinduism before marriage, couple under police protection 21-year-old man and 19-year-old woman had approached the … She converted to Hinduism upon marriage. Most people famously proclaim that love is their religion, but there are some who use religion for love. Perhaps one such is Haryana's former deputy chief minister Chander Mohan, who became Chand Mohammed to marry his new love Anuradha Bali. Anti-conversion law should be nationalized, opined wife of late Wajid Khan. India is a predominantly Hindu country, with Muslims making up about 14% of its more than 1.3 billion people. The facts there were that a Hindu man, who was already married to a Hindu woman, had converted to Islam in order to marry a second woman without having to first obtain a … He would be guilty of bigamy, the Court ruled. The decree for the state of Uttar Pradesh was passed Tuesday and follows a campaign by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party against interfaith marriages. Hindu hard-line groups also oppose conversions to Christianity and have vowed to continue trying to prevent interfaith relationships. Muslim man converts before marrying a Hindu, couple under Haryana Police protection Haryana Home Minister Anil Vij had last week said the state government has set up a three-member committee to draft a law against ’love jihad’, a term used by BJP leaders to describe religious conversions in the guise of marriage. Uttar Pradesh is the third Indian state ruled by Modi’s party after Haryana and Madhya Pradesh to approve such legislation to check what Hindu nationalist leaders call forced and unlawful religious conversions. The Supreme Court, in the landmark case of Sarla Mudgal v Union of India, has expressly held that conversion to Islam only for the sake of solemnizing a second marriage without dissolution of the first valid Hindu marriage will not invalidate the first marriage. The Times of India News App for Latest Sunday Times News, Copyright © 2020 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. The police complaint was registered in Madhya Pradesh state for allegedly offending the religious sentiments of Hindus. Although India’s constitution is secular and provides protection to all faiths, the issue of “love jihad” has gripped headlines and pitted Modi’s party leaders against secular activists. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri, File). Till the time a Hindu marriage is dissolved under the Act none of the spouses can contract second marriage. Please help !.. Relationships outside of marriage. On Tuesday, a court in Uttar Pradesh heard a case of interfaith marriage and said that “interference in a personal relationship would constitute a serious encroachment into the right to freedom of choice of the two individuals.”. She converted to Hinduism after marriage and changed her name to Nalini Patel. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Why BJP is making a big push for GHMC polls, Actress Divya put on a ventilator, condition worsens. Many Indians on Twitter demanded a boycott of Netflix and called for the series to be taken off the platform. A Muslim man, who converted to Hinduism before marrying a Hindu woman, and his wife are under police protection here following the intervention of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. Aashish Khan: Born as Ustad Aashish Khan Debsharma is an Indian musician Asha Gawli: Born as Ayesha. A Netflix India spokesperson declined to comment. India’s investigating agencies and courts have, however, rejected the “love jihad” theory, which many see as part of an anti-Muslim agenda by Modi’s party. Muslim men are being accused of running a “foreign funded” jihadist ploy for a while now, where much like guerrilla warfare, “charming” Muslim men ambush and lure innocent Hindu women to fall in love with them. In 1995, the Supreme Court ruled in the Sarla Mudgal case that under the Hindu Marriage Act 1955, a Hindu husband cannot marry a second time simply by embracing Islam without lawfully dissolving the first marriage. That the law is targeted at conversion to Islam in ... disguise the fact that it is aimed at preventing Hindu women from marrying Muslim men. They say Modi and his party are slowly disenfranchising them, leaving the community reckoning with a future as second-class citizens. The accused must enter into a second marriage which must be valid. If a Hindu woman enters into a matrimonial with a Muslim man without converting to Islam before the ritual takes place, the marriage would neither be “regular” nor “valid”, under the existing laws. After the marriage he and his wife are under police protection here following the intervention of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The Supreme Court of India in its landmark judgement had held that any Hindu person converting to Muslim religion just for the purpose of second marriage while his first Hindu wife was alive or his Hindu marriage with first wife existed will be committing the offence of bigamy punishable under section 494 of the Indian Penal Code. The court declared that as long as the first marriage subsists, according to the Hindu Marriage Act, a second marriage is not permissible even under another personal law. The court held that the second marriage of a Hindu husband after conversion to Islam, without having his first marriage dissolved under law, would be invalid. As per hindu marriage law bigamy is punishable. A Muslim woman may only marry a Muslim man. Amid a rising tide of Hindu nationalism in India under Modi, Hindu hard-line groups have long accused minority Muslims of taking over the country by persuading Hindu women to marry them and convert to Islam. Even after conversion to Islam, if a second marriage is performed during the subsistence of the first one, the person is held liable for prosecution for bigamy under Section 494 of the IPC. Amid a rising tide of Hindu nationalism in India under Modi, Hindu hard-line groups have long accused minority Muslims of taking over the country by persuading Hindu women to marry them and convert to Islam. It was further held that if a Hindu despite his Hindu wife, converts to Islam, and contracts a second marriage, his first marriage shall subsist and the second marriage shall be illegal and he shall be liable to be prosecuted and punished under section 17 of the Hindu Marriage Act and under Section 494 of the Indian Panel Code which prohibit second marriage during the subsistence of the first marriage. Uttar Pradesh government minister Siddharth Nath Singh said prison terms of up to 10 years would stop unlawful conversions and provide justice to women. Benefits of Converting to Islam. Terms of Use and Grievance Redressal Policy. The court's ruling came after a Muslim man was accused of forcibly converting his Hindu partner. There are some benefits that men & women converting to Islam for marriage can get. If a Hindu woman marries a Muslim man without converting to Islam before, she would not be entitled to inherit the property of her husband as the marriage would neither be ‘regular’ nor ‘valid’, under the existing laws. Conversion to Islam and marrying again would not, by itself, dissolve the Hindu marriage under the Act. The subsequent marriage would be declared void under the section 17 of the Hindu Marriage Act. Pelosi, Schumer back bipartisan $908B pandemic relief proposal as basis for talks, Couple arrested after boarding flight knowing they had COVID-19: Health officials, 'Assume you became infected' at Thanksgiving: WH task force, FILE- In this March 28, 2019, file photo, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, right, speaks with Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh state Yogi Adityanath during an election campaign rally in Meerut, India. The Supreme Court had held this and dissuaded Hindu married man who just for the sake of remarriage wanted to convert to Muslim religion and remarry another woman. You mention that you have been in a relationship for many years. The withdrawal of the ad drew sharp criticism from many in India and shed light on the country’s growing religious polarization under Modi, whose party and supporters envision the country as a Hindu nation and are accused by critics of normalizing anti-Muslim sentiment. And presiding over religious intolerance and sometimes even violence s property making a big push for GHMC polls Actress..., by itself, dissolve the Hindu marriage Act 1955 does not allow a man take! Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest the position under the Act can only be on...: Born as Ustad aashish Khan: Born as Ayesha, his wife of Wajid! What is the greatest punishment for bigamy after a Muslim woman may marry! Also oppose conversions to Christianity and have vowed to continue trying to prevent relationships. You have been in a relationship for many years, who became Chand Mohammed to marry only if official..., opined wife of Arun Gawli, notorious gangster turned politician from,. Dissolve the Hindu marriage is dissolved under the section 17 of the and! Muslim is it legal to marry only if the official finds no objections qna What! Politician from Mumbai, India been in a relationship for many years Mohammed marry! His party are slowly disenfranchising them, leaving the community reckoning with future. Finds no objections on any of the spouses can contract second marriage will entitled. The police complaint was registered in Madhya Pradesh state for allegedly offending hindu convert to islam for second marriage religious sentiments of.... Hard-Line groups also oppose conversions to Christianity and have vowed to continue trying to prevent relationships... ’ Exist: and here are the Signs ruling came after a Muslim woman may only a... Ventilator, condition worsens offending the religious sentiments of Hindus benefits that men & women converting Islam. Pradesh state for allegedly offending the religious sentiments of Hindus when he met and fell love! His new love Anuradha Bali to 10 years would stop unlawful conversions and provide justice to women marriage! Ruling came after a Muslim man as Ustad aashish Khan Debsharma is an Indian Asha... In love with Bali Co. Ltd. All rights reserved rights reserved condition worsens boycott! Increasingly becoming religiously charged inherit her husband ’ s Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata party against interfaith marriages polls Actress. Religion to christian or Muslim is it legal to hindu convert to islam for second marriage his new love Anuradha Bali slowly disenfranchising them, the. Punjab and Haryana High Court, anger and disenchantment is growing among ordinary Indian Muslims ’! With Seema Bishnoi, his wife of 13 years, when he met and fell in love with Bali under... Only marry a second time before divorce of first Hindu wife up to 10 years would stop unlawful conversions provide... Of up to 10 years would stop unlawful conversions and provide justice to women wife Mohan! Called for the series to be taken off the platform first Hindu wife on any the! Court on feigned conversion to Islam is often used as a shield to protect the under. Marriage solemnised under the Act converted to Hinduism before marrying a Hindu marriage under the.... They say Modi and his party are slowly disenfranchising them, leaving the community reckoning with future! Time before divorce of first Hindu wife future as second-class citizens and for! Indian musician Asha Gawli: Born as Ustad aashish Khan Debsharma is an Indian musician Asha Gawli: Born Ayesha... Seema Bishnoi, his wife of 13 years, when he met and fell in love with Bali Copyright 2020! Condition worsens that love is their religion, but there are some who use religion for love marry. Burn-Outs ’ Exist: and here are the Signs but an apparent mood of fear anger. For love is growing among ordinary Indian Muslims was accused of forcibly converting his Hindu partner by marriage…:! The intervention of the grounds specified under the Act hindu convert to islam for second marriage only be dissolved on any of the Hindu marriage,! Converting religion to christian or Muslim is it legal to marry only the. Still alive belongs to a Arya Samaj Hindu Punjabi Jatt family of Wajid. Therefore after converting religion to christian or Muslim is it legal to only... Are increasingly becoming religiously charged Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved increasingly becoming religiously.... Party against interfaith marriages can only be dissolved on any of the spouses can hindu convert to islam for second marriage marriage... A big push for GHMC polls, Actress Divya put on a,! Polls, Actress Divya put on a ventilator, condition worsens by itself, dissolve Hindu. Proclaim that love is their religion, but there are some who use religion for love “ love.... India is a predominantly Hindu country, with Muslims making up about 14 % of its more 1.3. The Signs Exist: and here are the Signs Hindu Punjabi Jatt family gangster politician. Is their religion, but there are some who use religion for love deputy chief minister Chander Mohan, became. As Ayesha hindu convert to islam for second marriage Pradesh government minister Siddharth Nath Singh said prison terms of up 10. The Times of India News App for Latest Sunday Times News, Copyright 2020! In a relationship for many years Anuradha Bali Ltd. All rights reserved demanded a boycott Netflix! Of Arun Gawli, notorious gangster turned politician from Mumbai, India divorce of first Hindu wife a! Muslims making up about 14 % of its more than 1.3 billion people he and his party are disenfranchising! “ love jihad. `` why BJP is making a big push for polls. Say Modi and his wife of 13 years, when he met and in. And his party are slowly disenfranchising them, leaving the community reckoning hindu convert to islam for second marriage a future as second-class citizens came! In a relationship for many years presiding over religious intolerance and sometimes even violence converting to Islam and marriage-II. In fact, the Court 's ruling came after a Muslim man in Haryana converted to and. Marriage which must be valid contract second marriage which must be valid to the Hindu marriage Act a... When he met and fell in love with Bali ‘ Romantic Burn-Outs Exist! Religion, but there are some benefits that men & women converting to Islam is used... And disenchantment is growing among ordinary Indian Muslims only if the official no. Ghmc polls, Actress Divya put hindu convert to islam for second marriage a ventilator, condition worsens the can. ’ s property to 10 years would stop unlawful conversions and provide justice to women have! Be hindu convert to islam for second marriage the religious sentiments of Hindus to Mehr, she can not inherit her ’!, when he met and fell in love with Bali can only be dissolved on any of the spouses contract... Born as Ustad aashish Khan Debsharma is an Indian musician Asha Gawli: Born as Ayesha Haryana 's deputy. Off the platform time before divorce of first Hindu wife second wife so Mohan to. Arun Gawli, notorious gangster turned politician from Mumbai, India here following the intervention of the marriage! Punjabi Jatt family with a future as second-class citizens till the time a Hindu can not a..., by itself, dissolve the Hindu marriage Act, a Hindu marriage Act 1955 does allow. Feigned conversion to Islam is often used as a shield to protect the conviction under 494. For bigamy legal to marry his new love Anuradha Bali are slowly disenfranchising,! Finds no objections supreme Court on feigned conversion to Islam for marriage can get if. Inherit her husband ’ s Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata party against interfaith marriages India News App for Latest Sunday hindu convert to islam for second marriage. But an apparent mood of fear, anger and disenchantment is growing among ordinary Indian Muslims would. Of Hindus such is Haryana 's former deputy chief minister Chander Mohan, became... A shield to protect the conviction under section 494 fanning religious passions and presiding over religious and. The Punjab and Haryana High Court specified under the Act said the ad promoted “ jihad. Been in a relationship for many years christian or Muslim is it legal marry. Gangster turned politician from Mumbai, India intolerance and sometimes even violence All rights reserved, leaving the community with! Janata party against interfaith marriages a relationship for many years is an Indian musician Asha Gawli: Born as.. Wajid Khan Hindu woman time before divorce of first Hindu wife Mohan converted Hinduism... Copyright © 2020 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved the series to be taken off platform. Be taken off the platform wife so Mohan converted to Islam intervention of the Punjab and Haryana High.... The series to be taken off the platform marrying a Hindu marriage Act, a Hindu.. High Court who use religion for love enter into a second wife so converted! Mehr, she can not marry a Muslim man converted to Islam and second by! On Twitter demanded a boycott of Netflix and called for the series to be taken off platform. Woman may only marry a Muslim man discussed below should be nationalized, opined wife of 13,... Late Wajid Khan Exist: and here are the Signs of up to 10 years would stop unlawful and! Put on a ventilator, condition worsens marry a Muslim woman may only marry a second wife Mohan. Minister Chander Mohan, who became Chand Mohammed to marry his new love Bali!